
Isaiah Mustafa
Biography
Isaiah Mustafa (born February 11, 1974 height 6' 3½" (1,92 m)) is an American actor and former NFLpractice squadwide receiver. Mustafa is widely known as the main character for a series of Old Spice TV commercials, The Man Your Man Could Smell Like, for portraying Luke Garroway on Freeform's fantasy series Shadowhunters, and as adult Mike Hanlon in It Chapter Two (2019). Mustafa was born in Portland, Oregon, the youngest of seven children of Shahidah Mustafa-Davis and John Wali Mustafa, who owned and ran a limousine service in Laguna Hills, California in the early 1980s. Mustafa studied history at Arizona State and he played during the 1997 Rose Bowl between the then-undefeated Sun Devils and the Ohio State Buckeyes. Although Mustafa expected to become a high school teacher after graduation, a sports agent suggested that he try out for NFL teams. The Tennessee Oilers signed him to the practice squad, then sent him to NFL Europe's Barcelona Dragons in 1998. After a season on the Oakland Raiders and Cleveland Browns' practice squads in 1999, Mustafa attended the Seattle Seahawks' training camp in 2000. Next he owned a restaurant called Jo Jo's Barbecue on Melrose Avenue in Los Angeles that has since closed. Mustafa is a comic book fan; his knowledge of Doctor Doom's first name helped him win $47,000 on The Weakest Link, for a question on the first name of Doctor Frankenstein. The money helped him pursue his post-restaurateur goal of becoming an actor.
Known For

TV
Grey's Anatomy
Brian Williams
2005

TV
NCIS
Oliver Newcomb
2003

TV
Chuck
Greta #2
2007

TV
Chuck
Rick Noble
2007

TV
Castle
Team Leader
2009

TV
NCIS: Los Angeles
Brent Duffy
2009

TV
Robot Chicken
Genie / Gerald Johanssen / Harlem Globetrotter (voice)
2005

TV
Anger Management
Paul Wesley
2012

TV
black-ish
Isaiah Mustafa
2014

TV
Cross
John Sampson
2024

TV
Hot in Cleveland
Kevin
2010

TV
Shadowhunters
Luke Garroway
2016

TV
Nikita
Cyrus
2010

TV
Ugly Betty
Bailiff
2006

TV
Baby Daddy
Captain Hudson
2012

TV
Sirens
Danny
2014

Film
It Chapter Two
Mike Hanlon
2019

TV
Femme Fatales
Raven
2011

TV
Eli Stone
Newlywed Husband
2008

Film
I Know What You Did Last Summer
Andrew
2025
Filmography
2025FilmI Know What You Did Last Summeras Andrew2024TVCrossas John Sampson2024FilmBoy Kills Worldas Benny2022FilmMurder at Yellowstone Cityas Cicero2022FilmThe Hostageas J.R.2022FilmHome Teamas Porcupine Coach2019FilmThe Summers of It - Chapter Two: It Endsas Self2019FilmIt Chapter Twoas Mike Hanlon2018FilmThe Clinicas Fletcher2017FilmFive Minutesas Roman2017TVTime for Bed with Punam Patelas Himself2016TVA Little of Your Time with Quinn Marcusas Himself2016FilmGirl Flu.as Gabriel2016FilmAfter the Realityas Garreth2016TVShadowhuntersas Luke Garroway2014TVSelfieas Mitchell McMoney2014TVblack-ishas Isaiah Mustafa2014TVSirensas Danny2014FilmBack in the Dayas T2013FilmCrushas Coach Evans2012TVAnger Managementas Paul Wesley2012TVBaby Daddyas Captain Hudson2012FilmRagsas Reginald Worth2012FilmMansomeas Self2012FilmThe Three Stoogesas Moe's Hip Executive2011TVCharlie's Angelsas Detective Ray Goodson2011FilmHorrible Bossesas Officer Wilkens2011TVFemme Fatalesas Raven2011FilmMadea's Big Happy Familyas Calvin2011FilmThunderballsas Ronnie2010TVNikitaas Cyrus2010TVHot in Clevelandas Kevin2009TVNCIS: Los Angelesas Brent Duffy2009TVCastleas Team Leader2008TVEli Stoneas Newlywed Husband2007TVChuckas Greta #22007FilmEven Moneyas Basketball Player (uncredited)2006TVUgly Bettyas Bailiff2005TVGrey's Anatomyas Brian Williams2005TVRobot Chickenas Genie / Gerald Johanssen / Harlem Globetrotter (voice)2003TVNCISas Oliver Newcomb